On October 1, the SEC’s Division of Examinations (“EXAMS”) published The SEC Exam Handbook: A Practical Guide on Process and Engagement (the “Handbook”), providing registrants with a detailed overview of the SEC examination process from the initial selection of a registrant through completion of an examination. 

The Handbook is intended to provide greater transparency regarding how EXAMS conducts examinations and what registrants should expect throughout the process. Although the Handbook applies broadly to entities subject to EXAMS oversight, it contains a number of practical observations particularly relevant to SEC-registered investment advisers. 

Among other things, the Handbook discusses how firms are selected for examination, how examinations are announced and scoped, the SEC’s expectations regarding document production, interviews and on-site visits, communications with examination staff, and the process for resolving examination findings. The Handbook also describes what EXAMS expects from registrants and what registrants can expect from EXAMS during an examination. 

Adviser Selection for Examination 

EXAMS reiterates that its examination program is risk-based. Each year, the Division evaluates risks across markets and registrant types and publishes examination priorities identifying areas of potentially heightened risk. However, those priorities are not an exhaustive list of the matters that may be examined in a particular exam. 

In determining which registrants to examine and the scope of particular examinations, EXAMS considers a wide range of information. Relevant factors may include a registrant’s prior examination history; disciplinary history of associated persons or affiliates; tips, complaints or referrals; the amount of time since registration or the registrant’s previous examination; the nature of its client base; products, services and potential conflicts of interest; changes in leadership or key personnel; financial or market stresses; media reports; regulatory filings; and access to client or investor assets. 

Importantly, EXAMS notes that selection for an examination does not necessarily indicate that the SEC believes something is wrong in how an adviser conducts its business and operations. EXAMS may not disclose the particular reason for an examination to the registrant. 

Before commencing an examination, EXAMS staff generally conducts due diligence to determine its initial scope, including reviewing the registrant’s regulatory filings and website. The Handbook therefore emphasizes the importance of maintaining accurate and current filings, noting that doing so can make examinations more efficient and reduce potential findings. 

Announcing an Examination and Information Requests 

Most examinations begin with a brief telephone call to the firm’s Chief Compliance Officer (“CCO”) or other regulatory contact, followed by a formal examination letter and initial information request. Although EXAMS notes that certain records should generally be readily available to staff, including within 24 hours of a request, staff typically provides approximately two weeks for a registrant to respond to the initial request. 

Supplemental requests may follow throughout the course of an examination. EXAMS encourages firms to communicate promptly regarding questions or concerns about requested information and indicates that EXAMS staff will consider reasonable requests for extensions or rolling productions where appropriate. 

The Handbook also addresses assertions of privilege. Where a firm withholds responsive information on privilege grounds, it should provide a privilege log identifying the document, relevant parties, date and subject matter, the specific privilege asserted and the examination request to which the document relates. 

EXAMS may also seek information directly from third parties, including custodians, administrators, and auditors, particularly for purposes such as verifying client assets. Staff may similarly contact clients, customers, or other knowledgeable persons when necessary to obtain or verify relevant information. 

Examinations are generally staffed by a team that generally includes one or more examiners, an exam manager, and an assistant director. Occasionally, senior members of the Division will participate in an exam; registrants should not take their presence as an indication that there are heightened concerns about their firm. 

Interviews and On-Site Visits 

Examinations frequently include an initial interview with the CCO or other personnel to help staff understand the registrant’s business and determine the examination’s scope. Additional interviews with employees may occur as staff reviews the information provided. 

The Handbook encourages registrants to make knowledgeable personnel available for interviews. EXAMS acknowledges that staff may ask seemingly basic questions about a registrant’s operations but explains that these questions are intended to establish a shared understanding of the business. This may be particularly important where an adviser employs novel investment strategies, products, or business practices. 

An examination may also include an on-site visit to the adviser’s offices. During such a visit, staff may request a tour of the registrant’s offices to understand its organization, workflow, and control environment. 

Of particular note, the Handbook addresses the use of technology during examination interviews. For videoconferences, EXAMS encourages the use of cameras and screen sharing. However, staff does not record or transcribe examination meetings and instructs participants not to do so. EXAMS specifically states that staff does not consent to the use of recording, transcription, artificial intelligence notetaking tools or similar technologies during examination meetings. 

Ongoing Communication with EXAMS 

The Handbook repeatedly emphasizes communication between the registrant and examination staff. Staff expect to remain in contact throughout an examination regarding outstanding requests, the status of the examination, and potential findings. 

Registrants are encouraged to inform staff about relevant developments and corrective actions undertaken during the examination. Similarly, if a registrant believes staff has misunderstood its policies, procedures or business practices, EXAMS encourages the registrant to raise the issue promptly rather than waiting until the examination concludes. 

This approach may provide firms with an opportunity to address factual misunderstandings, provide additional documentation, and begin remediation before the formal completion of the examination. 

Completing the Examination 

After completing its interviews and analysis, staff typically conducts an exit conference to discuss issues identified during the examination. EXAMS generally requests that senior management of the registrant attend these exit conferences. The registrant may provide additional information, correct perceived factual inaccuracies, and describe corrective actions already taken or planned. 

Following the examination, EXAMS will issue a disposition letter indicating that the examination has concluded, concluded without findings, or that the staff requests that the registrant undertake corrective action. A letter evidencing a request for corrective action is generally referred to as a deficiency letter, and the Handbook notes that most examinations conclude with a deficiency letter. 

A deficiency letter identifies potential violations or other findings within the examination’s scope but does not prescribe a particular corrective action beyond compliance with applicable law. EXAMS also emphasizes that deficiency letters do not provide grades, peer rankings or descriptions of “best practices.” 

Where a deficiency letter is issued, EXAMS typically requests a written response within 30 days describing the actions the registrant has taken or intends to take to address the findings and prevent recurrence. The Handbook specifically notes that prompt and appropriate corrective action, while not dispositive, may be considered a mitigating factor when determining whether an examination finding should be referred to the Division of Enforcement. 

The Handbook also provides some guidance regarding timing. Generally, EXAMS will provide a disposition letter within 180 days after completion of the on-site portion of the examination, if applicable, or receipt of all requested records, whichever occurs later, although certain complex examinations may receive an additional 180-day extension. 

Takeaway 

The Handbook provides SEC-registered investment advisers with a useful roadmap for preparing and managing an SEC examination. Although it does not materially alter advisers’ underlying regulatory obligations, it provides considerably more transparency regarding EXAMS’ procedures and expectations throughout the examination process. 

Advisers should consider the Handbook when evaluating their examination preparedness. In particular, firms should ensure that regulatory filings and public disclosures remain current and consistent with actual practices; books and records can be located and produced promptly; appropriate personnel understand their responsibilities during an examination; and procedures exist for coordinating document requests, interviews and communications with SEC staff. 

Firms should also consider establishing clear internal protocols regarding privilege reviews, responses to supplemental requests, escalation of potential examination findings, and remediation of identified deficiencies. In light of EXAMS’ specific statement regarding artificial intelligence notetaking tools, firms should ensure that personnel participating in SEC examination meetings understand EXAMS stated position that staff does not consent to the use of recording, transcription, AI notetaking tools or similar technologies during examination meetings.   

More broadly, the Handbook reinforces that an examination should be approached as an ongoing process rather than simply a document production exercise. Prompt communication, accurate regulatory filings, knowledgeable personnel, organized records and timely remediation can all contribute to a more efficient examination and provide the firm with opportunities to address potential misunderstandings or compliance concerns before the examination concludes.